Imagine the possibilities for your Toyota Tacoma pickup.
What if you could achieve a five-mpg increase in your Tacoma pickup? Would you be willing to invest $2,000 and pay an extra $.80 per gallon if it meant a significant improvement in your vehicle's performance and fuel efficiency?
In a recent Toyota Tacoma Owners Facebook post, Dustin Thomas shared his success story. He claims to have boosted his 2025 Tacoma SR 4WD pickup's gas mileage by a minimum of five miles per gallon.
Many Tacoma owners, like Dustin, are striving to enhance their vehicle's fuel efficiency. But the question remains, at what cost?
Let's Take a Look
Dustin says, "I just wanted to take a second and admire the MPG I've been getting in my 2025 Toyota Tacoma SR 4WD. I've had the truck for almost four months now as its first owner, and my mileage has been increasing little by little every month."
"When I first got the truck, it was around 21-22 mpg consistently, and I was running regular 87 octane with the factory cold air intake (CAI)". It's the same drive to and from work every day: 46 miles each way. In the last month and a half or so, I've seen noticeable gains in my MPG that have been in the mid-high 20s."
"For context, I live in the NW Georgia area with a mix of mountainous/hilly areas. I drive 46 miles to and from work on the highway 5 days a week going between 55-65 MPH (a couple of speed trap zones, but mostly going 60-65 mph)."
"The highest I've gotten was 29.2 MPH. I also have a SXTH CLT, Flowmaster Super 44 Series Exhaust, and I consistently run 93 octane."
"I say all of this to say that for those who say an aftermarket CAI or running 93 octane doesn't help performance, just from what I've observed and continue to observe, it has made a tremendous impact on my performance since switching to those things!"
What does a Flowmaster Super 44 Series Exhaust cost?
The cost ranges from $1,000 to $1,400, depending on the system. Please note that this does not include the cost of installation.
Automotive shops typically charge an hourly rate between $75 and $130 per hour. A complete exhaust system replacement generally takes 2 to 3 hours, resulting in labor costs ranging from $150 to $390.
What level of performance improvement can Tacoma owners expect?
While Flowmaster exhaust systems are designed to improve exhaust flow and potentially reduce backpressure, the horsepower gains are usually modest. Jegs suggests gains of 5-10 horsepower are typical, especially when paired with other modifications.
What does a SXTH Off Road CPLT Cold Air Intake cost?
The price of the SXTH Off Road CPLT Cold Air Intake for the 2024-2025 Toyota Tacoma is $399.00 USD.
The promo material says it provides enhanced airflow, improved engine performance, and increased horsepower and torque. "No tuning is required for installation, except for Trailhunter and TRD Pro models, which will require custom tuning."
So, now the custom upgrades have cost about $2,000.
Will running premium 93 octane gas improve fuel mileage in the Toyota Tacoma?
Tacoma owners on Reddit and the Tacoma Forum report that it's generally not worth running 93 octane premium gas in a 2025 Toyota Tacoma unless it's specifically tuned for it. The 2025 Tacoma's engine is designed to run optimally on 87-octane regular fuel.
Is There a Performance Benefit?
Using higher octane fuel, such as 93, will not provide any noticeable performance gains (like increased horsepower or improved fuel economy) in a stock Tacoma, according to Toyota of Braintree and Fuel Logic.
Note: The only exception is if you've modified your Tacoma with a performance tune that requires explicitly higher octane fuel. In that case, you'll need to use what the tune specifies.
What is the cost of 87 octane gas per gallon?
AAA says the national average is $3.22 per gallon.
What is the cost of 93 octane gas per gallon?
The national average price for 93-octane premium gasoline is $4.059 per gallon, according to AAA Fuel Prices.
So, that's approximately $15 more every time you fill the Tacoma's 18-gallon tank with a premium grade compared to regular 87-octane gas.
So, Dustin spent about $2,000 to outfit his truck with a Flowmaster Super 44 Series Exhaust System and a CPLT Cold Air Intake system; additionally, he spends an extra $ 0.83 per gallon to run premium 93 octane gas.
All for a five mpg gain in gas mileage. Is it worth it?
What Do You Think?
There are readers out there who are far smarter than I am. There may be an engineer or a mathematician who can calculate how long it takes to realize savings with the amount spent ($2,000) and on buying premium gas, which offers no benefits anyway.
Will Dustin still own the pickup when it does? We're eager to hear your thoughts. Click the red 'Add New Comment' link below and share your calculations.
Check out my Toyota Tacoma story: I Hate My 2023 Toyota Tacoma, It’s Underpowered, Uncomfortable, the Transmission is Awful, and the AC Isn’t Cold Above 80, I’m Buying A Tundra
I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Reporter since 2012. My 30+ year tenure in the automotive industry, initially in a consulting role with every major car brand and later as a freelance journalist test-driving new vehicles, has equipped me with a wealth of knowledge. I specialize in reporting the latest automotive news and providing expert analysis on Subaru, which you'll find here, ensuring that you, as a reader, are always well-informed and up-to-date. Follow me on my X SubaruReport, All Subaru, WRXSTI, @DenisFlierl, Facebook, and Instagram.
Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Dustin Thomas
Comments
No way, your looking at a…
Permalink
No way, your looking at a vacum gage ,it will not unless you trick the 02 sensors or due a mod tune.the computer will not!!! Not let you get better mpg ,that's the problem ,the emissions will through un burnt gas out your tailpipe before you get better mpg .or go overseas were you dont have this ridiculous emissions.
With the numbers provided,…
Permalink
With the numbers provided, getting +5 mpg.. It costs .003 cents more per mile just to run premium before adding upgrades. So he is out $2k and spending extra for fuel
If he just used regular gas …
Permalink
If he just used regular gas (not premium) I get that he will break even at 73,804 miles. If he uses premium, he'll never break even with gas costing $0.80 more per gallon. The extra cost of the premium gas eats up any savings he is gettng with the better fuel economy.
I'm not an engineer either…
Permalink
I'm not an engineer either... but math is not on this mans side. 3.22/gal averaging 22 mpg is roughly 0.146/mile. (14.6 cents per mile) vs 4.06/gal averaging 27 mpg is roughly 0.15/mile (15 cents per mile)
So he is still spending more per mile due to the increased cost of fuel. He'd have to be getting 28mpg on 93 to break it even. And even at 30mpg it he would be saving 1 cent per mile. Driving 92 miles per day commute he would save .92/cents per day, and it would take him 2,173 days to recoup the 2k he invested in the parts/install. On a 5 day work week (not taking into account holidays, PTO, sick days etc) that means he works 260 days a year, meaning it would take him over 8 years to break even.
So.... yeah. Not worth it. If you want cool intake and exhaust notes, go for it. But the math doesn't support doing it for cost savings.
Those cold air intakes are…
Permalink
Those cold air intakes are nothing but snake oil. And as far as the exhaust system goes, I usually just wait until the factory system rots off. As I did with my last car. And my neighbors muffler shop welded on one of those used flow master muffler at a fraction of the cost. Because said muffler was used, and the prior owner thought that it was too loud.
Actually a question... does…
Permalink
Actually a question... does the truck still have the catalytic converter? If not, there's your mileage increase.
After 209,187 miles you'll…
Permalink
After 209,187 miles you'll recoup your costs. Nice!
It is completely common for…
Permalink
It is completely common for vehicles to improve in MPG as they break in. And with premium fuel. The exhaust and the air intake likely had little to nothing to do with it.
If you are so concerned…
Permalink
If you are so concerned about fuel economy, why didn’t you buy a Prius?
The reason your mileage…
Permalink
The reason your mileage improves is because of break in on drive train.
Higher octain fuel does not deliver better mileage due to the fact all gas levels have the same specific energy.
Too bad you still cannot keep up with a stock ranger.
Don't believe it. No matter…
Permalink
Don't believe it. No matter what you do to that truck your gas mileage isn't going to improve as much as you say. If it was possible Toyota would be doing it from the factory because they have a huge incentive to meet and exceed government standards for manufacturers. Plus you kill any warranty repairs you may need in the future. Foolish to spend that much money to maybe get 1 or 2 MPG's better.
First let me say if I drive…
Permalink
First let me say if I drive 60-65 mph, my bone stock 2016 ram 1500 pentastar gets 27 mpg on 87 octane. That being said if Toyota could get a 29mpg Tacoma by tweaking the intake and exhaust I'm sure they'd do it. The cost for Toyota to install such equipment would be drastically less than what this guy paid. Fact is Toyota, and ram, and Ford, are surprisingly qualified and very competitive on these matters of engineering. He's definitely wasting his money on 93 octane gasoline as the engine wasn't designed to run on 93 octane and actually you will get less power by not using the recommended octane
As others have stated, the…
Permalink
As others have stated, the mileage I crease is likely due mostly to the break-in of the powertrain. Even if running premium does manage to give a 5mpg boost the extra price makes it nearly identical in cost for a given distance. Likely the premium MAY contribute to a 1 or 2mpg increase at most, so would be more expensive.
In regards to the 2000 upfront, I would say as long as it wasn't 100% to try and get better mpg then why not. It will never pay itself back via fuel savings (for having a less restrictive system) but if you want a nicer sound and maybe some better throttle response(depending on the setup) then go for it. But don't do these mods for the sake of fuel savings.
They need to run it on regular gas for awhile again and see if there's a difference, but 100% I'd be running regular gas in that
I have just under 1500 miles…
Permalink
I have just under 1500 miles on my 2025 Tacoma SR5 and can average 26 mpg on interstate by keeping my damn foot out of it and I'm running 87. Cost me nothing. 😂
I bet the mpg increase was…
Permalink
I bet the mpg increase was due to the switch from winter gas to summer gas, not due to any of the owner's modifications
I have tried running on 93…
Permalink
I have tried running on 93 Oct ( premium) and got that 5 extra mpg when compared by same route, same price same time of day drive , full tank, make the test drive refill and calculate, one have to try replicate even your gas feet pressure, without doing any tuning or change. Obviously with a new tunned exhaust, kn filter might get another 3@5 improvements by same driving conditions.
If it's mileage you desire,…
Permalink
If it's mileage you desire, Toyota makes a wonderful truck called the Prius. Trucks get truck mileage, in case you didn't know.
I swear my 21 extended cab 4wd Tacoma was bigger than my dad's full size 81 F150. They are not small fuel efficient trucks. Well, compared to the Mastodons the big three make, I guess they small-er. I'll stick with my "new" 04 Tacoma 2wd and its 25 city 28 hwy mpg.
I get that without all the…
Permalink
I get that without all the hassel. You just learn how to drive smarter, and take life at a slower speed.